Do you deliver?

Delivery is available on all orders for an additional fee, which is calculated based on mileage and time requirements. Contact Us for a delivery quote.

We do recommend that all large party cakes and wedding orders be delivered, as we come prepared to stage your dessert table so it integrates perfectly with event decor.

How far in advance should I order my desserts?

We are committed to delivering the highest possible quality to each of our customers. For this reason, we limit the number of orders we accept each week. Placing your order as far in advance as possible will help you ensure you get the product you want for the date you want!

However, we always do our best to accommodate last-minute orders. Contact Us to see if your date is still available!

Recommended Order Timelines

Wedding Cakes: 3-6 months

Custom Cakes + Cupcakes: 4 weeks

Cakes + Cupcakes: 2 weeks

Cookies: 2 weeks

Speciality Desserts: 2 weeks

How do I get a quote or place an order?

Getting a quote or placing an order with Guilty Pleasures Bakeshop + Bar is simple.

Stop by our bakeshop, complete our contact form or get in touch with us by phone or email to initiate the process.

Try to include as much of the following information as possible when making your inquiry:

Date/time of event

Type of event


Number of servings required

Flavour preferences

Design ideas/special requests

Applicable allergies


We’ll get back to you within 1 business day with a quote and then we will work together to firm up all details before confirming your order.

A minimum deposit of 50% is required to confirm all orders.

Do you offer any unique cake/frosting flavours?

Yes! If you’re looking to up the dessert ante, try one of the custom flavour combinations we’ve developed in-house. We’re constantly concocting delicious new cake recipes so check back before your next event.

If you have an idea for an interesting new flavour, send it our way! We love to experiment with unique combinations!

See available flavours

What are my choices for cake flavours?

We have a wide range of standard and premium cake flavours and we are always creating new flavours.

See available flavours

What are my choices for filling flavours?

We have a wide range of filling flavours to please any taste buds.

See available flavours

What’s included in the cake decoration pricing?

A festive message and sprinkles are included in the starting price of each cake. You may also choose from a variety of included buttercream textures, such as ripple, rustic, or rosettes.

Additional design features such as buttercream flowers, fondant, intricate piping, figures, etc. will add to the cost of your cake.

Can you replicate a cake I found on Pinterest, Instagram, etc.?

If you find an image of a cake made elsewhere we can definitely use it to inspire your cake design. Please note, however, that we do not make exact replicas of existing cake designs.

Other great places to find inspiration for your cake include party theme/colours, invitations, linens, etc.

What if I want a custom designed cake?

We are happy to discuss your cake design vision and ideas! Custom cake designs are priced based on the amount of time and materials needed to create your vision.

Please Contact Us to check availability, get a quote or for more information.

How do I store my cake and cupcakes?

Buttercream or ganache cakes can be stored in original packaging at room temperature for 3-4 days. If your home is warm and/or humid, store the cake in the refrigerator. Cakes frosted with whipped cream, cream cheese or mascarpone frosting, or containing any type of custard or fruit filling must always be stored in the refrigerator.

For best flavour and texture, let your cake rest at room temperature for a few hours before serving. Larger cakes may need additional time to warm up.

IMPORTANT NOTE: If your cake or cupcakes are covered in fondant or have any fondant decorations, DO NOT refrigerate or freeze. Store the cake at room temperature in original packaging. Once the cake has been cut, you can cover and refrigerate it according to the directions below.

Storing Leftover Cake:

If you happen to have leftover cake (we don’t understand people like you!), simply cover all of the exposed areas of the cake in plastic wrap. Then, store at room temperature or in the refrigerator for up to 4 days (from the date of purchase). You can also tightly wrap the entire cake in a layer of plastic wrap, followed by a layer of aluminum foil, and store in the freezer for up to 1 month.

Can you accommodate our dietary restrictions?

Guilty Pleasures Bakeshop + Bar is happy to accommodate all dietary restrictions, offering nut-free, egg-free, vegan, dairy-free and gluten-free options for most desserts. We are meticulous about containing contaminants, however, we cannot guarantee that cross-contamination will never occur.

If you have allergies, please contact us to discuss your order.